5309 BAY AVE, Ocean City, New Jersey

Public property record for 5309 BAY AVE in Ocean City, Cape May County, New Jersey — tax assessment, lot details, and sales history from official New Jersey records.

Property Facts

• Property class: Residential
• Year built: 1966
• Lot size: 0.15 acres (55 × 115 ft)
• Building area: 2,039 sq ft
• Land assessment: $376,800
• Improvement assessment: $199,700
• Total assessment: $576,500
• Latest annual tax: $6,468

The most recent assessment values 5309 BAY AVE at $576,500 total ($376,800 land plus $199,700 improvements).

Sale History

• 2025-09-26 — $995,000

Nearby Properties on Block 5306

• 5300 SIMPSON AVE
• 10-12 53RD ST
• 5304 SIMPSON AVE
• 5308 SIMPSON AVE
• 5312-14 SIMPSON AVE
• 5316 SIMPSON AVE
• 5320 SIMPSON AVE
• 5324 SIMPSON AVE
• 5328 SIMPSON AVE
• 9-11 54TH ST

See more in Ocean City property records, Cape May County property records, or the Ocean City sales history.