5404 BAY AVE, Ocean City, New Jersey

Public property record for 5404 BAY AVE in Ocean City, Cape May County, New Jersey — tax assessment, lot details, and sales history from official New Jersey records.

Property Facts

• Property class: Residential
• Year built: 1967
• Lot size: 0.11 acres (50 × 95 ft)
• Land assessment: $323,400
• Improvement assessment: $130,400
• Total assessment: $453,800
• Latest annual tax: $4,841

The most recent assessment values 5404 BAY AVE at $453,800 total ($323,400 land plus $130,400 improvements).

Sale History

• 2025-10-23 — $1,975,000
• 2025-01-30 — $687,500

Nearby Properties on Block 5407

• 5400 BAY AVE
• 5408 BAY AVE
• 5412 BAY AVE
• 5416 BAY AVE
• 5420 BAY AVE
• 5424 BAY AVE
• 5428 BAY AVE
• 5432 BAY AVE
• 5436-38 BAY AVE
• 237 ANCHORAGE DR

See more in Ocean City property records, Cape May County property records, or the Ocean City sales history.